Monday, June 29, 2009

Local unemployment raging-- time for green-job-creating Dutchess County Green Homes program!...

[note-- Babylon Town Supervisor Steve Bellone will be speaker forum tomorrow Vassar College Rockefeller Hall Rm. 300-- "Bringing Sustainable Energy Infrastructure into the Hudson Valley"-- sponsored by Hudson River Sloop Clearwater, Sustainable Hudson Valley, Hudson Valley Smart Growth Alliance, Vassar College Sustainability Committee, & Independent Dutchess Energy Alliance!]


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Hi all...


Miss this one in the Journal June 19th?...[from "Unemployment Up in May" by Craig Wolf]...


[see: http://www.poughkeepsiejournal.com/article/20090619/BUSINESS/906190327/1003 ]


"Joblessness jumped back up in May in the mid-Hudson Valley and the state after a brief downturn in the preceding months, offering a sign the impact of the recession is still with us. Unemployment in Dutchess County was 7.4 percent in May, which is 10,900 people, the state Department of Labor said Thursday. It's the highest May level since 1993. That's up from 4.9 percent a year earlier and up from 6.8 percent recorded in April. "The Hudson Valley Region continues to be adversely affected by the current economic downturn, as evidenced by this month's 2.3 percent over-the-year decline in private-sector employment," regional labor analyst Johny Nelson said in his monthly statement.
"Outside of educational and health services, all industry sectors continue to show over-the-year job declines," Nelson said. The coming months will likely show more loss because of layoffs already planned by various employers."


Well-- check out http://www.LIGreenHomes.com -- for a great green-jobs example we need here!...


...and send a letter NOW to all 25 of us at countylegislators@co.dutchess.ny.us to make this happen!...


[all-important monthly Committee Chairs mtg. is tomorrow for Co. Leg.-- your letters needed now on this]


[thanx to Dover Co. Leg. Pete Wassell for agreeing to co-sponsor resolution below; more needed tho!]


The Town of Babylon voted last August to set up a two-million-dollar revolving loan fund to help local homeowners afford free to low-cost energy audits and energy-efficiency retrofits, with savings on electric bills paying off those loans, with a population there of 211,000 people; Dutchess County should step up to the plate and start a three-million-dollar revolving loan fund for this purpose, for our population of 300,000-- as a local Green New Deal job-creating program inspired by Dutchess County's own FDR and Eleanor Roosevelt...(again-- see http://www.LIGreenHomes.com for yourself on this!)...


[also see-- "In Babylon, an Incentive for Energy Efficiency" by Carolyn Nardiello (NYTimes 1/15/09)
http://www.nytimes.com/2009/01/18/nyregion/long-island/18greenli.html ]


Fact: Sustainable Hudson Valley Chair David Dell, a Poughkeepsie resident and cofounder of the Independent Energy Alliance (modeled after http://www.CambridgeEnergyAlliance.org ), has crunched the numbers and determined that literally one billion dollars in savings on electric bills over the next decade could be put back into the pockets of Dutchess County homeowners, businesses, municipalities, and taxpayers if Dutchess County seriously followed the good example of programs like the Long Island Green Homes program and the Cambridge Energy Alliance-- programs that make it much easier than otherwise for homeowners and others to get free to low-cost energy audits and energy-efficiency retrofits.


Fact: Every year our County Legislature votes to consider many millions of bonds for various purposes; a bond for a Dutchess County Green Homes program would be money well-spent that would go right into the pockets of local homeowners to help them save on utility bills.


Fact: Making energy audits and energy-efficiency retrofits much more readily available to homeowners will automatically lessen our county's dependence on fossil fuels like home heating oil and energy from the Danskammer/Roseton coal-burning power plant complex in Newburgh-- and so clean up local air quality and cut local carbon emissions from our county dramatically.


Fact: Globam warming is a very real phenomnenon right here in our region-- "since the 1970's average winter temperatures [here in Northeast] have risen more than four degrees."[see http://www.350.org ]
[ http://www.climatechoices.org/assets/documents/climatechoices/NECIA_climate_report_final.pdf ]


Fact: There are over 39,000 people in Dutchess with asthma, bronchitis, or emphysema; many of them on Medicaid (cleaning local air quality will save Medicaid tax $$$); see http://www.ALANYS.org .


Fact: Back in May the DEC issued an air quality health advisory for two days straight for
Dutchess, Ulster, Columbia, and Greene counties.
[see: http://www.midhudsonnews.com/News/2009/May09/21/Air_quality-21May09.htm ]


Fact: Just last month Dutchess County's air quality was rated an "F" in a new American Lung Association of New York State "State of the Air" report.
[see: http://www.alany.org/site/c.kmKWJbNTJtF/b.5071049/k.926/State_of_the_Air_2009.htm ]


Fact: Dr. Gary Lovett of the Cary Institute of Ecosystem Studies pointed out publicly two years ago in Millbrook forum that vast majority of local ozone pollution problem is from transportation sources.


Fact: According to Clive Jones and Jillian Gregg of the Cary Institute of Ecosystem Studies, ground-level ozone air pollution here in Dutchess County is worse than in NYC.
[see: http://www.news.cornell.edu/releases/July03/ozone_trees.hrs.html ;
http://www.nytimes.com/2003/07/10/nyregion/city-trees-outgrow-rural-cousins-and-study-credits-urban-chemistry.html ; http://www.ecostudies.org/images/newsletter/07-08_2003.pdf ]


Fact: The Long Island Green Homes program amounts to a de facto local version of the statewide Green Jobs/Green Homes NY proposal to create green jos and help homeowners save on electric bills-- proposed by Assembly Energy Chair Kevin Cahill, Center for Working Families, NYS Apollo Alliance, NY League of Conservation Voters, Citizens Campaign for the Environment, NYPIRG, Natural Resources Defense Council, Environmental Advocates of New York, and Audobon NY.
[ http://www.CenterforWorkingFamilies.info ]


Since early this year I've been trying to get a resolution passed in our County Legislature to get a Dutchess County Green Homes program off the ground similar to the Town of Babylon's Long Island Green Homes program-- see http://www.LIGreenHomes.com -- such an initiative could be a wonderful complement to the Independent Dutchess Energy Alliance (two resolutions already spearheaded by yours truly thru our Co. Leg. over the last year to get IDEA going)...


So again-- your letters needed NOW-- to all 25 of us at countylegislators@co.dutchess.ny.us, folks!...


[pass it on]


Joel
242-9017/876-2488
joeltyner@earthlink.net

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

From: "Nicholas Zuba"


Here are the basic statistics we have for the Long Island Green Homes program.


Long Island Green Homes Statistics as of May 19, 2009

o Number of Jobs Completed - 58
o Number of Audits Completed - 122
o Number of Jobs in Progress - 49
o Number of Inactive Jobs - 24
o Total Cost of Projects - $398,883.71
o Average Project Cost - $6,997.96
o Average Annual Savings for Homeowner - $995.66
o Average Payback Period (years) - 7.64
o Total Carbon Dioxide Saved (annualized) - 156 tons
o Total Solid Carbon Saved (annualized) - 96,773 pounds

Nicholas Zuba
Legislative Aide to the Supervisor
Town of Babylon
200 East Sunrise Highway
Lindenhurst, NY 11757
Phone: (631) 957-3054
Work Cell: (516) 779-4653
Fax: (631) 957-7440
E-mail: nzuba@townofbabylon.com


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

[note-- thanks much to Co. Leg. Pete Wassell for agreeing months ago to co-sponsor this resolution]

WHEREAS, most homes in Dutchess County have not been constructed to building performance standards that conserve energy; the overwhelming majority of homes here are wasting considerable amounts of energy and contributing unnecessary greenhouse gasses to the environment; leaking energy means that homeowners are wasting a lot of money; with fuel costs at all time highs and in a region where utility rates are among the highest in the nation, homeowners can no longer afford to waste energy, and

WHEREAS, the Long Island Green Homes Program is a self-financing residential retrofit program in Babylon, New York and a good example for Dutchess County to follow to upgrade the energy efficiency of existing homes here; the program can enable residents to make their homes greener and healthier at little or no out-of-pocket cost; often residents will save money immediately from making improvements such as more efficient lighting, weatherstripping, caulking, air and duct sealing, insulation and upgrading of heating units, and

WHEREAS, in the Long Island Green Homes Program, Town of Babylon licensed Green Homes contractors conduct comprehensive energy audits of homes to determine what energy-efficient home improvements may be effective; those contractors then prepare detailed reports demonstrating the savings homeowners can receive after making those improvements; usually those savings cover the cost of the upgrades, and

WHEREAS, there are no up-front costs to the homeowner for the improvements suggested in the Long Island Green Homes Program; even the nominal fee for Home Performance Evaluations are applied to the cost of the improvements; once licensed contractors hired to make improvements to homes have completed the work, the Town of Babylon directly pays those contractors, and

WHEREAS, after that, homeowners then pay the Town of Babylon for the improvements on a monthly basis for an amount and term that is agreed upon in advance; in most cases the savings from reduced energy bills will be greater than the cost of the improvements meaning the home owner will have a positive cash flow; the money that was going to the utility companies now goes to make Dutchess County's homes greener and healthier, and once the improvements are completely paid for all of the savings go directly to the homeowner, and

WHEREAS, in the Long Island Green Homes Program, the Town of Babylon is not making loans directly to residents; the Town is expanding the definition of solid waste to include energy waste, based on its carbon content; by defining energy waste in this way, the Town of Babylon is able to provide energy-efficient improvements to Babylon residents' homes from its solid waste fund; this type of measure is known as a "benefit assessment", and

WHEREAS, a benefit assessment can be established when a municipality provides a specific improvement on a parcel of property for a public purpose, assessing the cost of the benefit against the property; in the case of Long Island Green Homes, the energy-efficient improvements to homes serve a vital purpose, remediating the environmental damage caused by leaky and inefficient homes, and

WHEREAS, the Town of Babylon is now providing for energy saving improvements up to $12,000 per home, and homeowners are paying for the improvements through a monthly benefit assessment fee; the amount of the monthly benefit assessment fee is structured to be less than the monthly savings on a resident's energy bills resulting from the energy-efficient improvements; the Town of Babylon is charging a 3% administrative fee which will be built into the monthly payments residents will make to pay for the improvements, now, therefore, be it

RESOLVED, that the Dutchess County Legislature requests that our county's Departments of Planning and Development, Public Works, and Finance evaluate the cost and feasibility of a Dutchess County Green Homes program for here similar to the successful Long Island Green Homes program and report back to the County Legislature in sixty days on this, and, be it further

RESOLVED, that a copy of this resolution be sent to our county's Departments of Planning and Development, Public Works, and Finance.


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -


From http://www.nytimes.com/2009/01/18/nyregion/long-island/18greenli.html ...


"In Babylon, an Incentive for Energy Efficiency"


By CAROLYN NARDIELLO
New York Times January 15, 2009


LINDENHURST-- Until it was repaired, a faulty spring on a pull-down attic staircase allowed heat to seep through a two-inch gap at the ceiling of Michael and Peggy Chambers¹s split-level home here, resulting in higher heating bills. ³We were heating the attic,² Mr. Chambers said.

Mr. Chambers, 58, senior associate executive director of psychiatry at Woodhull Medical and Mental Health Center in Brooklyn, and Mrs. Chambers, 52, an aide at Harding Avenue Elementary School in Lindenhurst, said that they knew other energy-saving repair work was needed on their modest four-level residence, but that they could not afford the thousands of dollars to pay for it.

But when the couple received a pamphlet last summer from the Town of Babylon about the Long Island Green Homes initiative, a program that would cover energy-efficient home improvements at little or no upfront cost to homeowners, they decided to participate.

A few weeks ago the Chamberses became the first residents in Babylon to have energy-efficient improvements completed.

Any of Babylon¹s 65,000 homeowners who qualify can receive up to $12,000 worth of energy-efficient work done by employees that the town contracts with.

What makes the initiative different from other green home initiatives is the method by which the town has obtained money for the upfront improvement costs.
Homeowners pay off the amount of the improvements from savings on their utility bills.

Dorian Dale, the town¹s energy director, said redefining solid waste to include carbon allowed officials to get access to $2 million from the town¹s solid waste management fund. The Town Board approved the plan in August.

³The program is cost effective, helps our environment and helps our economy,² said Steve Bellone, the Babylon town supervisor.

The Chambers family received $8,000 worth of work ‹ eight Energy Star windows, insulation in their bedroom walls, crawl spaces and attic, plus a new pull-down staircase and hatch leading to it. Mr. Chambers said that his home is warmer and that the work, which took four days to complete, has increased the home¹s value.


³We never would have done it ourselves,² he said.

A $250 fee paid by the Chamberses for a three-hour energy assessment will be subtracted from the cost of the improvements and a 3 percent administrative fee will be added to the bill for the home improvements.

Michael Deering, vice president of environmental affairs at the Long Island Power Authority, said the Babylon plan is the only one in the area he knows of that uses public money for energy-efficient home improvements.

Nassau County¹s deputy director of environmental coordination, Bradford Tito, has been working on a Levittown green homes program since last year in which homeowners receive loans for the improvements. Mr. Tito said that the economic downturn had made less cash and credit available to homeowners but that since the program began, residents had increased energy conservation efforts.

Under Babylon¹s plan, the money for renovations comes from the solid waste fund, not in the form of a bank loan. Under terms agreed upon with the town, families repay the money, presumably from savings in energy costs, over a set period of time.


The Chambers family anticipates saving $100 a month on their energy bill and will pay about 80 percent of that monthly to the town for eight years.

If they or other homeowners in the program decide to sell their properties, the repayment plan is passed to the new homeowners.

Sammy Chu, the deputy commissioner of Babylon¹s Department of Public Works, said the town aims for a projected savings amount in energy bills that will cover improvement expenses, but warns that may not always be the case. The town can, however, ease payment terms.

The Chamberses, who have four daughters, ages 17 to 24, said that with the economic downturn, the plan makes sense.


³Right now people don¹t have money and if they do, they¹re going to spend it on something else,² Mrs. Chambers said, adding that she is pleased with the work on her home. ³It¹s almost like a godsend.²


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

From http://www.LIGreenHomes.com itself...

Frequently Asked Questions about our unique, money saving program:

What is the Long Island Green Homes Program?

It is a self-financing residential retrofit program for upgrading the energy efficiency of existing homes in the Town of Babylon. The program will enable residents to make their homes greener and healthier at little or no out-of-pocket cost. Often, residents will save money immediately from making these improvements.

Why is the Green Homes Program necessary?


Most homes­even newer ones­have not been constructed to building performance standards that conserve energy. The overwhelming majority of homes on Long Island are wasting considerable amounts of energy and contributing unnecessary greenhouse gasses to the environment. Leaking energy means that homeowners are wasting a lot of money. With fuel costs at all time highs and in a region where utility rates are among the highest in the nation, homeowners can no longer afford to waste energy.

How do I save money with the Green Homes Program?

A Town of Babylon Licensed Green Homes Contractor will conduct a comprehensive energy audit of your home to determine what energy-efficient home improvements may be effective. The contractor will prepare a detailed report that will demonstrate the savings you will receive from making the improvements. The savings will, generally, cover the cost of the upgrades.


Who pays for the energy-efficient home improvements?


The best part of the Long Island Green Homes program is that there are no significant up-front costs to the homeowner for the improvements. The nominal fee for the Home Performance Evaluation (the $250 for the audit) will be applied to the cost of the improvements. Once the licensed contractor has completed the work, the Town will directly pay the contractor. The homeowner will then pay the Town for the improvements on a monthly basis for an amount and term that is agreed upon in advance. With almost every customer, the savings from reduced energy bills will be greater than the cost of the improvements. This means that the homeowner will have a positive cash flow; the money that was going to the utility companies is now going to make your home greener and healthier. Once the improvements are completely paid for all of the savings go directly to the homeowner, saving him/her an average of $984.30 every year.

Is the Town loaning money to homeowners?

The Town is not making loans to residents. The Town is expanding the definition of solid waste to include energy waste, based on its carbon content. By defining energy waste in this way, the Town is able to provide energy-efficient improvements to Babylon residents¹ homes from its solid waste fund. This type of measure is known as a ³benefit assessment.² A benefit assessment can be established when a municipality provides a specific improvement on a parcel of property for a public purpose, assessing the cost of the benefit against the property. In the case of Long Island Green Homes, the energy-efficient improvements to homes serve a vital purpose, remediating the environmental damage caused by leaky and inefficient homes. The Town will provide for energy saving improvements up to $12,000 per home and the homeowner will pay for the improvements through a monthly benefit assessment fee. The amount of the monthly benefit assessment fee is structured to be less than the monthly savings on a resident¹s energy bills resulting from the energy-efficient improvements. The Town will charge a 3% administrative fee which will be built into the monthly payments residents will make to pay for the improvements.

How do I proceed?

Before we can schedule you for a Home Performance Evaluation, we need some information about your home's energy use. Please fill out the Self-Check Home Inventory Form, which includes some basic questions about your home, as well as your energy usage habits. Also, you will need to obtain two (2) years worth of utility usage data from your utility providers. Retrieving this information is easy, just visit your utility provider's website, or give a call to the customer service line. Once we have processed the data from your Self-Check Home Inventory Form, a Town of Babylon Licensed Green Homes Contractor will perform a Home Performance Evaluation on your house. The contractor will provide a detailed report that will recommend certain energy efficient home improvements and estimate the savings that will result. You make the decision to hire the contractor to perform the energy-efficient home improvements. What energy-efficient home improvements are offered through the program? Improvements include efficient lighting, weatherstripping, caulking, air and duct sealing, insulation and upgrading of heating units, etc. We will advise participants which appliances, cooling units, and other eligible measures offer the best return and what LIPA rebates and incentives apply. Please call our office at (631) 422-4411 if you have any further questions or concerns.

What if I make the improvements and sell my home soon after?

When you sell your home the benefits associated with the energy efficient home improvements pass automatically to the new homeowner, so it is only fair that any remaining costs for the improvements will also pass automatically. Once you sell your home your liability for any additional payments is over.

How does the Green Homes Program benefit our environment?

By reducing the amount of energy needed to power our homes we will significantly reduce greenhouse gas emissions that are causing global warming. Every time we turn a light on in our homes or turn up the thermostat or turn on an air conditioner, we are using energy from a power plant or burning scarce fossil fuels (oil and natural gas), all of which produce greenhouse gas emissions. By combating global warming and cleaning the air, you are also preventing the need to build more power plants and are reducing our reliance on fossil fuels.

Will my house assessment be increased or my taxes increase as a result of making these improvements?

Absolutely not. Any energy-saving improvements made to your home through the Long Island Green Homes program will not increase your home¹s assessment or increase the amount of taxes you pay.

Will the Town be inspecting my house to do these improvements?

Absolutely not. You will be hiring a contractor as you would for any other type of work you would want to do in your house. The only difference here is that the contractors are licensed by the Town to insure they have the credentials and capability to properly do this kind of work. At no time will Town employees be permitted to enter your home without your explicit permission.

Why is it called the Long Island Green Homes Program?

Although the program is starting in Babylon it is our expectation that it will be replicated throughout Long Island and New York State. The potential benefit to homeowners, to our environment and our economy is too substantial for this program to be offered only in Babylon. The name also reflects the fact that this program is in line with regional and statewide objectives under the leadership of New York State Governor David Paterson. Governor Paterson¹s Renewable Energy Taskforce recently proposed a roadmap to pave New York¹s way to energy independence including the need for comprehensive building efficiency. In addition, Kevin Law, President and CEO of the Long Island Power Authority (LIPA) recently released his Efficiency Long Island Program, which emphasizes making homes more energy-efficient.


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

More from http://www.LIGreenHomes.com ...

1. Getting Started

Before we can schedule you for a Home Performance Evaluation, we need some information about your home's energy use. Please fill out the Self-Check Home Inventory Form or by calling the LIGH Hotline: (631) 422-4411). Besides answering simple questions about your home, you will be asked to provide two years of billing and usage data from your utility providers. If you do not have the information available, it is easy to request it from your utility providers¹ website or ask the LIGH Hotline representative for help. All of this information will give us a good indication of whether or not it is worth it for you to have a Home Performance Evaluation.

2. Get a Home Performance Evaluation

Once your Self Check Home Inventory Form is received in the LIGH office, our staff will call to schedule a Home Performance Evaluation which will be conducted by a Town-licensed, BPI Accredited energy auditor. The audit will cost $250, which is to ensure your commitment to the program. If you end up participating in the Green Homes program, the $250 would go towards the cost of the alterations we would perform on your home. We will not recommend a home performance evaluation (audit) unless we think that you could benefit from our program. The energy audit takes place at your house and is a series of tests designed to identify areas of your home that can benefit from energy efficiency improvements.

3. Receive Your Report

Following the Home Performance Evaluation, you will be given a detailed explanation of how your home uses energy, where the most energy is being wasted or lost, and specific improvements that could increase energy efficiency. The report also calculates a fixed cost for each recommended improvement along with the projected dollar amount you will save on your utility bills.

4. Make Energy Efficient Improvements

Your Town-licensed, BPI-accredited private contractor enters into a contract directly with the Town and will make the recommended energy-efficiency improvements to your home that you choose to have completed. The work typically takes only one to three days to complete.

5. Receive a Benefit Assessment to Finance Improvements

The Long Island Green Homes Program pays the contractor the entire cost of the energy-efficiency improvements. Under a separate contract with the homeowner, the Town sets up a monthly payment plan that has the homeowner pay for the improvements over time only from projected utility bill cost savings. For example, if our expert Home Performance Evaluation auditors project that you will save $1,000 per year in utility bills, the Town will establish an annual payment schedule (benefit assessment payment) that amounts to less than the projected savings.

6. Pay Back Over Time, Using the Money You Save on Energy Bills

Because these improvements are permanent fixtures to your home, every homeowner qualifies for the Program to pay for the improvements ­ there is no need to provide any personal credit score or financial history. Instead of paying inflated electric, oil or gas bills, you pay for the energy efficiency improvements from your utility bill savings. If you move and sell your house during the payment term, the remaining payments stay with the house and are taken over by the new owner until paid off in full.

Friday, June 26, 2009

Congratulations to Sam Kogon-- for winning Sixth Annual Dutchess County Legislature District #11 Essay Contest!...

Hi all...

Congratulations to Rhinebeck High School's Sam Kogon for winning the Sixth Annual Dutchess County Legislature District #11 Essay Contest (and savings bond) this year!...(see his essay just a bit below; lots of good ideas there)...

[am posting this online now before commencement exercises so that folks interested in reading his actual essay can go to this blog/website once I announce it at graduation tonite]

For the last five years (since 2004) I've sponsored a District #11 Essay Contest for graduating high school seniors in Rhinebeck and Clinton-- the challenge being an essay of five hundred words or less on what they would do if they were in my position (county legislator for Clinton and Rhinebeck); over the years these young men and women have come up with a number of good ideas (see last year's winning essays below; sign on to http://www.petitiononline.com/ouryouth if you agree!)...

Essay contest award winners this year as in the past will be awarded with savings bonds and certificates from our County Legislature (last year this was possible thanks to the generosity of Rhinebeck's Duncan Christy, Janet Stetson, and Frances Sandiford, among others)...

Recall graduating Rhinebeck High School senior Rachel Neifeld's award-winning essay several years back (see http://www.petitiononline.com/teencntr -- effort started by yours truly for local teen center with folks like John Honey):

Rachel then wrote: "I would put great effort into creating a place for teenagers to associate after nine o' clock. Instead of having to travel to Kingston to find some night time entertainment, there should be a casual setting for people to reside in the center of town. A community center in the heart of Rhinebeck would provide kids with reasonably priced food and events during late night hours when other options are limited. This desperately needed social setting, dedicated to the youth of the town, would be a great place to grab a bite to eat after a movie, or just relax with friends on a Friday night. With something to do, kids may be less likely to have drinking parties at friends' houses, and would not resort to unhealthy recreational decisions."

[note-- if you haven't yet, see Young Rhinebeck's website on this: http://www.YoungRhinebeck.org ]

Again-- just a bit below is this year's winning essay from graduating senior Sam Kogon-- along with last year's award-winning essays from Rhinebeck High School graduating seniors Kayla Arsenault, Forrest Hackenbrock, Alex Landa, and Scott McDonald...

[many good ideas-- but just as it takes a village to raise a child-- it takes a village/town to make their dreams come true!]

Joel
242-9017/876-2488
joeltyner@earthlink.net

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

From Sam Kogon...

"Realistically, there are many wonderful things about living in Rhinebeck/Clinton that do not need to be changed. However, there are other aspects that could use a bit of a tweaking to make it an even better place to live. If I were in a position to bring about change, I believe that we need to do all we can for our working families so they can afford to continue to reside here. The area has all the signs of becoming a weekend community for city dwellers. Our stores, restaurants, and town in general caters mainly to the needs of the weekender. There are very few businesses that offer merchandise that is both affordable and necessary to actual residents. Even our farmers market has prices that very few locals can afford. This needs to be addressed to keep our year round residents both comfortable and happy.

If I were the County Legislator, I would also continue to work towards a greener way of life. Our schools already recycle but that this could be taken a step further by using only natural cleaning products, having compost piles, and utilizing the most energy efficient products available. Our local government buildings should become showcases for the green movement, as well. 

As of late, there have been more recreational offerings for our area's youth. The town committees seem to have sensed that kids need places to go and things to do to keep them from having too much free time on their hands. If I were a County Legislator, I would take this even a step further. I would put together a county wide youth advisory board made up of teens from all the towns in Dutchess. As a group, they could get more done and also learn from each other. If county officials sat in on these meetings, they could learn what is needed and then work to bring more opportunities to our youth.

As the economy has weakened, there are less employment opportunities available for our youth. Rhinebeck High School does run a youth employment service during the school year. I would propose running it through the summer months as well. I would also advertise it  so that local people could hire teens and college students for jobs such as babysitting and lawn care. This would keep Rhinebeck and Clinton young people busy and also allow them to have spending money. 

Rhinebeck/Clinton is a wonderful place to live. Change, not stagnation,  is a process that will keep it that way for our future residents."

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

From Kayla Arsenault...

"Growing up in Rhinebeck I've come to notice the Fairgrounds rarely used. Using the Fairgrounds for events such as concerts that our local Hudson Valley bands could play at, a local drive-in movie theatre, family potluck days, and various competitions would be an effective use of the Fairgrounds space. The local bands would gather the surrounding towns creating a stronger community. Many people from around this area would come spread or get inspiration from this event. Local businesses will benefit greatly from this because many people will stop and eat or shop at Rhinebeck's local businesses. Also another plus would be that teens would get into less trouble because they would be attending these events instead of having free time to do whatever they please.

To make families closer it would be great to have family field days. May through August would be acceptable months to have this because it would be after the car shows but before the fair. Things such as cook-offs, go-cart racing, and bull-riding would be fun and exciting for people to attend. For these events we could invite local business vendors to serve, display, or market their business' food. By gathering the residents of the community it would truly strengthen our neighborhood.

Another way to use that space would be to have a drive-in movie theatre. This would give a place for kids to go at night and is also closer than the Hyde Park drive-ins. Some ideas for this would be classic movie night for the seniors and late-night movies for teens and adults.

I'm hoping that you will take these ideas into consideration considering the fast growth in crime in Rhinebeck. Involving kids, teens, and adults back into the community is the main purpose of these ideas-- so if you make any of my ideas reality, I'm positive that a lot of things will change around Rhinebeck."

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

From Alex Landa...

"Rhinebeck, New York- a rather beautiful town, with an old-fashioned comfort that's rare these days. It's become a famous place to raise the young, and for the elderly to enjoy their wisdom years. Where does the middle stand, the teens, the young adults, and the working family? To be honest, many teens and even adults find it difficult to have a good time in town. This is a fairly stale area in all honesty, which has many people, teens and even adults resort to doing hard drugs and drinking their time away. I've lost friends due to this circumstance, and the idea of an internet café could spark some creativity through artistic means, as opposed to resorting to artificial means.

This town lacks the creative side, as it's focused on entertaining the elderly and wasting too much time making artificial beauty to bring in naïve spenders from large cities, primarily New York City. Although the town has its fair share of narrow-minded people, who take natural beauty for granted, there are still the ones who need a spot to be with other artistic people, sharing their works, and having a mentally safe environment. I propose to make an internet café, of which is fairly self explanatory; a café with Wi-Fi connection, but with more. I also propose to include two separate venues to the side, one being an art gallery of which could be updated periodically. The second venue would be used for different occasions each week, one week it could be an open mike night, a battle of the bands, poetry slam, karaoke, plays be performed, and even setting up a projector and have a film festival.

Not only could this generally bring a lot of amusement to Rhinebeck, it could greatly improve the economy. It would create new jobs; have builders create the new building, people running the café, setting up internet, creating the events, and so on. It would bring more people to Rhinebeck, as this idea doesn't seem too common in Dutchess County, so it could potentially have people bring their disposable income, which could go to the school, and fixing up some less that adequate roads and sidewalks throughout Rhinebeck. It could easily relieve parental worries; I'm sure they'd rather have their child come home fatigued from creative stimuli rather than narcotic stimuli.

Rhinebeck, New York- beauty, relaxation, calmness, and low crime rate. Rhinebeck, New York- stale, drug filled, and not the best place for the middle range. This town needs spice, the cinnamon on top of a well-made cappuccino. Helping the economy, destroying boredom, potentially lowering the drug problem, and bring some more creative elements, I see, might not be a bad thing. My purpose for said proposal is to improve a town of which seems to dearly need improving. Lest we not forget, in today's day and age, living in a whirlwind of social demons, even this small addition to Rhinebeck could serve as a sanctuary to young, elderly, and middle range alike."

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

From Forrest Hackenbrock...

"If I were county Legislator I would focus on a few things. First I would attempt to survey the youth in the area, maybe by going to elementary high schools and asking various groups to fill out questionnaires. In the survey there should be questions about what kids would like to see more of in our area. I feel that in the town of Rhinebeck and Clinton, there is a lack of recreational resources for kids. The mini park is mainly for toddlers and younger kids. The rec park and Crystal Lake are the only other area in town that kids can play sports or hang out. These facilities are in good condition and provide recreation but there could be more. There is a quite large skateboarding community that is oppressed by a lack of skate spots. If there was even a small skate park, at the rec park or somewhere near by town, I think a lot more kids would be active and interested in such activities. I believe kids in our community would also benefit from a community center where they could just hang out, play pool, etc. If there were to be a stage where bands could perform I know it would flourish. I know this is easier said than done but with the right sponsors and support it is a possibility.

Another thing I would concern myself with is environmental issues. I feel that many people in Rhinebeck and Clinton are involved with the green movement while others may not be. There should be public service announcements telling quick tips or facts on how to reduce our destruction of the environment. These could be billboards, or small signs around town, or commercials on the radio or TV. Our community must be aware of our carbon emissions levels and take a stricter approach on littering.

The town of Rhinebeck obviously caters to tourists, especially from New York City. I enjoy our town and find it very unique and interesting. I like how the only corporation is CVS. Corporate involvement should be kept to a minimum in our town. As I walk through town I notice all the new establishments are upscale, and do not represent locals' needs. There should be more stores with practical items and prices, along with restaurants.

I moved here in 2000, and did not like it very much. However, as I grew up, Rhinebeck grew on me, and I am now very happy and privileged to be living here. I think we are living on a high standard and should maintain that. The suggestions I made are the only improvements I can think of, because Rhinebeck is a very well established town. As long as the town can communicate with the community, the harmony that exists will continue to live on."

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

From Scott McDonald...

"In a town like Rhinebeck where poverty and crime are almost nonexistent, other subjects come to mind when I consider what could be changed to better our community. Our community as well as our country as a whole misuses resources, create ridiculous amounts of waste, and operate in an inefficient manner. I feel it is appropriate and necessary for me to use Rhinebeck High School, the institution with which I am most familiar under our local government, to demonstrate these observations as well as provide alternative modes of action.

Everyday Rhinebeck High School deposits hundreds of sets of styrofoam trays and plastic silverware in the trash. To me, this waste is inexcusable. It would not only be cost efficient, but it would relieve a huge environmental burden if our school would just decide to buy real plates with real silverware and wash and reuse them each day. Also, Rhinebeck High School continues to feed the kids processed, canned garbage from some large food processing company located in the middle of nowhere when they could be providing healthy produce and supporting local agriculture at the same time. The school could also set aside a piece of land for growing fresh fruits and vegetables and use it as an opportunity to teach kids agriculture and nutrition as well as provide community service opportunities.

The school district also tends to use artificial light instead of natural sunlight by keeping the window shades closed and turning the lights on, frequently to keep kids from being distracted by the outside world. This is wasteful in terms of electricity and energy, not to mention artificial light has been shown to be less stimulating to students in a learning environment. For the times when artificial light is necessary, the school should have full spectrum light bulbs installed as it is proven to be more likely to keep students alert, healthier for the body chemically, and cost effective in the long run.

If I were county legislator for Rhinebeck and Clinton, I would try to impact the school system for several reasons. Not only is the system run poorly, but if done correctly, instilling values of conservation and local agriculture in the youth now would go on to prove very beneficial to both our town and the world in the future."

Thursday, June 25, 2009

Co. Leg. resolutions passed but not implemented by County Exec, dept. heads-- why county charter needs to be changed...

Hi all...

Have you seen the Dutchess County Charter?...

[call our County Attorney's or County Legislature's offices for a copy]

Over and over again it notes in article .01 of about twenty different sections that all county department heads are "directly responsible to, and serve at the pleasure of, the County Executive"...

Fact: A number of county department heads have told me to my face that they have been reminded of this all too often by the County Executive himself or his underlings.

Many suspect this is why the seventeen resolutions below I've spearheaded passage of through our County Legislature over the last eighteen months (along with many others passed after being initiated by others in my caucus) haven't been implemented by various county department heads; also-- a number of county department heads and employees in various departments have told me repeatedly over the last six years I've been in our County Legislature that they have been warned to not even communicate with a Democrat in the County Legislature-- never mind actually implement a resolution passed in a Dem-led County Legislature...

This is not democracy; the citizens and taxpayers of Dutchess County deserve better-- far better, friends...

So-- send a letter now on this to all 25 of us in our County Legislature-- at countylegislators@co.dutchess.ny.us-- for the Dutchess County Charter to be changed-- so that the County Executive no longer has the power to summarily fire at will any of the twenty or so department heads below-- but that a vote by a simple majority in our County Legislature would also be necessary (besides the County Executive's moving to do so) to remove a county department head!...

Don't believe me-- see for yourself-- the fact is that now, according to the Dutchess County Charter, all of the following county department heads are "directly responsible to, and serve at the pleasure of, the County Executive":

Article 5 Computer Information Systems Commissioner

Article 6 Finance Commissioner

Article 7 Health Commissioner

Article 8 County Attorney

Article 9 Mental Hygiene Commissioner

[Article 10 deleted in 1993-- re: Dept. of Parks and Conservation; now under DPW]

Article 11 Personnel Commissioner

Article 12 Planning and Development Commissioner

Article 13 County Public Defender

Article 14 Public Works Commissioner

Article 15 Real Property Tax Commissioner

Article 16 Social Services Commissioner

Article 17 Solid Waste Management Commissioner

Article 18 Emergency Response Commissioner

Article 30 Office for the Aging Commissioner, Veterans Affairs Commissioner, County Historian, Youth Board Commissioner, Consumer Affairs Commissioner Probation and Community Correction Commissioner, and Medical Examiner

Ball's in your court, folks-- send emails on this now to countylegislators@co.dutchess.ny.us!...

Joel
242-9017/876-2488

p.s. Here's a list of seventeen resolutions I've spearheaded through our County Legislature just in the last eighteen months alone-- none of whom are being implemented by various county department heads (as all can be fired at will by the County Executive as it stands now for even communicating with a Democrat in our County Legislature-- never mind actually following through on these resolutions passed in our County Legislature):

1. For a zero-waste approach to resource recovery in our county-- to save money and create clean green jobs.

2. For cost-saving green roofs, rain gardens, wind turbines, and composting toilets to be on county property (note-- resolution for this just passed this month-- so-- hopefully this one implemented soon!).

3. For solar panels on County Office Building at 22 Market St. in Poughkeepsie (then all county buildings).

4. For free energy audits of all county buildings to be done by company like Johnson Controls, Honeywell, etc.

5. For Dutchess to save on power costs w/Municipal Electricity Gas Alliance (like Putnam, Ulster, Sullivan co.'s).

6. For saving 30% on lighting bills in county buildings by switching fixtures from T-12's to T-8's, metal halides.

7. For new SuperLOOPer discount card at local stores and restaurants for frequent users of LOOP bus system.

8. For Dutchess County to hold Home Heating Summit re: home heating oil crisis (as in Ulster, Orange co.'s).

9. For Dutchess ESAN "Recommendations for Stream and Flood Management in Dutchess" to be followed.

10. For a Green Map to be added to county website to list farmer's markets/green resources (as in Westchester).

11. For a bike rental program in Dutchess County at no cost to taxpayers (as is already in Washington, D.C.).

12. For a bulk-rate discount sale to county residents of rain barrels and compost bins (similar to Lake Co./Ill.).

13. For Dutchess County to be included in Hudson Valley Community Preservation Act to protect open space.

14. For county's Health Department to publicly report on chloramines in public water supplies in county.

15. For listing of restaurants using oils without trans fats to be added to county's Health Department website.

16. For recycling plastics #3, #5, #7 and recycling bins being placed next to all public trash containers in county.

17. For a cost-saving "Green House Project" nursing home to be in county- proven to make seniors happier.

County electeds should pay for at least 15% of health insurance...

Hi all...

Since last fall I've been pushing with G.O.P. Co. Leg. Bob Sears for Dutchess County to be more like other counties in region (except Orange)-- and make county legislators and other elected county officials pay for at least 15% of health insurance benefits (as 2000+ rank-and-file CSEA-member county employees do already (one way to cut county budget and give more money back to taxpayers)...

Sign on to my http://www.petitiononline.com/cutlgpay if you agree w/minimum 15% insurance co-pay!....

[click on "view current signatures" to see comments from fifteen signed on to endorse this already--
Rhinebeck's Alice Wilbeck and Duane Watson, LaGrange's Diane Sommer and Dana Tompkins,
Red Hook's Wendy Ewald, Doris Soroko, and George Quasha, Millbrook's Kate Farrell and Margaret De Wys, Poughkeepsie's Dick Anderson, Carmen McGill, Ed Pittman, and Doug McComb, Fishkill's Connie Hogarth, and Wappinger's Rich Carlson]

Fact on this from today's Journal article-- "The county could save about $127,000 to $509,000 if the 195 employees and elected officials were to contribute 5 percent to 20 percent of their premiums - the range most employees pay, according to Journal research."
http://www.poughkeepsiejournal.com/article/20090625/NEWS01/906250332/Dutchess-elected-officials-get-higher-pay--perks&referrer=FRONTPAGECAROUSEL

Click here for task force report-- http://www.poughkeepsiejournal.com/assets/pdf/BK137329624.PDF .

[D. Freeman: http://www.dailyfreeman.com/articles/2009/06/25/news/doc4a42f9763c7bc926973752.txt ;
MidHudsonNews http://www.midhudsonnews.com/News/2009/June09/25/DC_gov_sals-25Jun09.html ]

Got a sec?...Send a letter to all 25 of us at countylegislators@co.dutchess.ny.us-- for action on this now!

[pass it on]

Joel
242-9017/876-2488

p.s. Of course the real health care solution is to expand Medicare to cover everyone-- would save $350 billion a year for the U.S.-- why Hinchey and 82 other members of Congress are signed on to Conyers' H.R. 676-- see http://www.SinglePayerAction.org ; http://www.1Payer.net ; http://www.PNHP.org !...

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

From today's Journal....

Dutchess elected officials get higher pay, perks
Survey compares county to 12 in region

BY JENNY LEE-ADRIAN • POUGHKEEPSIE JOURNAL • JUNE 25, 2009

http://www.poughkeepsiejournal.com/article/20090625/NEWS01/906250332/Dutchess-elected-officials-get-higher-pay--perks&referrer=FRONTPAGECAROUSEL


Dutchess County provides above average salaries and benefits for top elected officials compared to similar counties in the mid-Hudson Valley and across the state, according to a legislative task force report released Wednesday.

Dutchess and Orange were the only two counties among 13 surveyed that reported offering free health insurance benefits for all elected officials. Greene County elected officials pay nothing toward their premium if their start date is before Jan. 1, 2009, but after that date the contribution is 15 percent, Hammond said. The other counties that responded to the survey require elected officials to contribute 5 percent to 25 percent of the cost of their insurance. Rockland County did not provide information.

In terms of salary, the base pay for Dutchess legislators was the median for the 13 counties, but all other salaries for elected officials - county executive, comptroller, clerk, sheriff and legislative leaders - are above the average and the medians for each group, according to the report from the Dutchess Legislature Compensation Task Force.

Looking For Savings

The survey looked at the salaries and benefits provided to Dutchess elected officials and compared them to counties in the region and those of similar population, budget and employment. Chairman Roger Higgins, D-New Hamburg, has said he wants to use the information to look at ways to save money.

In February, the Journal investigated salary and benefit packages. Health insurance costs are a sizeable chunk for government budgets. This year, the county will spend about $2.5 million to provide health insurance for 195 employees and elected officials who are not required to contribute to their premiums, the Journal investigation found.

The county could save about $127,000 to $509,000 if the 195 employees and elected officials were to contribute 5 percent to 20 percent of their premiums - the range most employees pay, according to Journal research.

Higgins has talked about offering a payment to elected officials to opt out of the county health insurance plan to save money down the road.

In fact, the task force report showed Dutchess and Rensselaer counties do not offer an "opt-out" payment among the counties surveyed, task force member James Hammond said. Sullivan, Broome, Rockland and Niagara counties did not provide information on the issue.

"Clearly, we should be doing that, too," Higgins said.

While the Journal report also looked at cell phones and cars provided to the county executive, sheriff, district attorney and county clerk, the task force report surveyed the counties about cars provided to the county executive and sheriff. Of the seven counties that responded to the survey, Dutchess was one of three to provide a vehicle for the county executive. Dutchess was among the six counties out of 10 counties responding to pay for a car for the sheriff.

The task force only released information on elected officials and will submit a report on management salaries and benefits this year.

The Center for Governmental Research, a nonprofit, gathered the information for the task force. The Dyson Foundation provided a grant of up to $50,000 to pay the research group to conduct the survey, task force member Hammond said.

The report also showed legislators are paid slightly below the average annual salary of $19,128 in the selected group of counties, but the $15,450 annual salary for each Dutchess rank-and-fine legislator is the median salary.

However, stipends for majority and minority leaders in the Legislature were well above the average, according to the report. The chairman of the Legislature in Dutchess County receives a $17,511 stipend, compared to the average of $10,858 in other counties. The majority and minority leaders in Dutchess get stipends of $8,511, compared to the average of $900 in other counties. Dutchess also provides assistant minority and majority leader positions, which have stipends. Of the 11 counties that responded, Dutchess was the only county to offer pay for the assistant leaders.

Based on the report, Higgins said he doesn't see any salary increase for the comptroller or for legislators this year since their compensation is near the average.

The vote to raise the salaries of legislators and the comptroller comes up in July, Higgins said.

"I have concluded that while Dutchess County's elected officials are not the highest compensated officials of the counties surveyed, they are still fairly compensated," Higgins said. He said he's open for more discussion if legislators wish to address the matter at a later date.

Assistant Minority Leader Robert Rolison, R-City of Poughkeepsie, agreed.

"I don't see any reason to increase legislative salaries," Rolison said. "That's for sure."

As for making any changes to health insurance benefits, Rolison said the issue needs to be looked at. The report will spur discussion, he said.

High pay

Salaries for the county clerk, sheriff, legislators or board chairpersons and county executive are above average in the group.

County Clerk Brad Kendall's annual salary of $106,023 is about 30 percent above the group average of $87,434, the report said. Sheriff Butch Anderson's annual salary of $125,664 is about 20 percent above the group average of $101,107.

Higgins' annual salary and County Executive William Steinhaus' salary are about 10 percent above the group average in each category.

Reach Jenny Lee-Adrian at leeja@poughkeepsiejournal.com or 845-437-4835.

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

From http://www.midhudsonnews.com/News/2009/June09/25/DC_gov_sals-25Jun09.html ...

Elected Dutchess officials are ‘fairly compensated,’ says legislature chairman

POUGHKEEPSIE – A comparative study of the salaries of Dutchess County elected officials shows they are “fairly compensated and no salary adjustment is in order at this time,” according to County Legislature Chairman Roger Higgins.

Higgins formed a task force to look into compensation for county elected officials and management personnel.

“I think certainly the report, coupled with the current economic climate in the county; it’s the prudent thing to do.”

County Legislature Minority Leader Gary Cooper agreed with Higgins’ assessment. “There is really no need for anybody to be looking for a raise and I don’t think anybody was looking for a raise, but it was a good study to have done.”

The study found that Dutchess County Executive William Steinhaus has the third highest salary of those counties examined. With a paycheck of $139,869, he comes in behind Orange County Executive Edward Diana at $166,718 and Putnam County Executive Robert Bondi at $148,635.

Behind Steinhaus is Rockland County Executive C. Scott Vanderhoef, at a salary of $137,765; and Ulster County Executive Michael Hein, at $133,580.

The Putnam County comptroller/chief financial officer receives a salary of $125,611; in Orange county, the salary is $112,607; in Ulster County, the salary is $101,709; Dutchess comes in at $99,938; Sullivan County’s salary is $99,000; Rockland County’s is $77,170; in Greene County, the salary is $74,083; and in Columbia County, it is $61,785.

Rank and file county legislator salaries range from $35,136 in Putnam, $32,587 in Rockland, $27,281 in Orange, $21,606 in Sullivan, $15,450 in Dutchess, $15,000 in Greene, $14,000 in Columbia and $10,000 in Ulster County.

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

From http://www.dailyfreeman.com/articles/2009/06/25/news/doc4a42f9763c7bc926973752.txt ...

NEWS
Noting salary study, Dutchess chairman rules out some raises
Published: Thursday, June 25, 2009

By PATRICIA DOXSEY
Freeman staff


ELECTED officials in Dutchess County are among the highest paid in the area and are on par with county leaders elsewhere in the region and state.

Based on that revelation, county Legislature Chairman Roger Higgins said on Wednesday that Democrats who control the chamber won’t consider pay raises for legislators or the county comptroller for 2010-11.

“It seems to me elected officials in Dutchess County are pretty well compensated,” said Higgins, D-New Hamburg.

The salaries of county leaders across the region were detailed in a report by a task force appointed by Higgins in January. The task force was charged with reviewing the compensation and benefits of county elected officials and management personnel.

The study was funded by a $50,000 grant from the Dyson Foundation and compared Dutchess County salaries to those in Ulster, Columbia, Greene, Sullivan, Oneida, Broome, Rockland, Niagara, Orange, Putnam, Rensselaer and Albany counties.

According to the study, Dutchess County Executive William Steinhaus, with a $139,869 annual salary, is the third-highest-paid executive in the region, behind only those in Putnam and Orange counties, which have executive salaries of $148,635 and $166,718, respectively.

Steinhaus oversees a county of roughly 292,000 people and a budget of $392.7 million.

In addition to his salary, Steinhaus, a Republican, receives free health insurance and the use of a county-owned car.

Ulster County Executive Mike Hein is paid $133,580, pays about 15 percent of his health insurance costs and does not have a access to a county-owned vehicle.

Hein, a Democrat, was elected in November to become Ulster County’s first executive. Ulster County has roughly 182,000 people and a budget of $332.2 million.

The Broome County executive, who oversees a county of 196,300 people and a budget of $416 million, is the lowest paid county executive in the study, with a salary this year of $87,657.

Columbia and Greene counties do not have county executives.

Dutchess County’s rank-and-file legislators, with salaries of $15,450 per year, are higher paid than legislators in Ulster, Greene and Columbia counties but fall in the middle of the salary range of the counties surveyed. The lowest-paid legislators are in Oneida County, with an $8,368 annual salary. Putnam County legislators, at $35,136, are at the top of the scale.

Like legislators’ pay, Dutchess County Comptroller Diane Jablonski’s salary of $99,938 fell in the middle of the 13-county pay range. While her salary was significantly above that paid to finance officers in Columbia and Greene counties, it was below the $101,709 salary paid to Ulster County Comptroller Elliot Auerbach.

In addition to their salaries, all elected officials in Dutchess receive free health insurance and life insurance through the county. But unlike some other counties, Dutchess does not offer a monetary incentive to officials who “opt out” of the county’s health plan.

In 2007, Republicans in the Dutchess County Legislature failed in two attempts to muster support to give pay raises to the county executive, sheriff and clerk.

Under Dutchess County law, the salaries of elected officials must be set in the July prior to the November election for the seat.

Because all 25 members of the Dutchess County Legislature, as well as the county comptroller, are up for election this year, any salary increases for those officials must be approved next month.

“We have no intention of increasing the salary for the Legislature or the comptroller,” Higgins said of the Democratic majority.

The second phase of the study, which will focus on management salaries, is under way and should be completed in late summer or early fall.

Wednesday, June 24, 2009

Call Albany, Washington toll free asap this week, folks!...

[originally sent this out Tues. afternoon-- but much below still pertinent; fwd along to all you know!]

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Hi all...

State Senate in session today!...see "Senate Deadlock Heads Into Special Session" by Joseph Spector:
http://www.poughkeepsiejournal.com/article/20090623/NEWS/90623013&referrer=FRONTPAGECAROUSEL

So-- time is now to call state Senators toll-free-- at (877) 255-9417...(see Laura Haight email below!)...

[see much more re: priority green legislation here-- http://www.eany.org/capitolwatch/billratings.html ]

Scroll down to see urgent alert from MoveOn to get all in House signed on to Pingree-Ellison letter too...
[see: http://pol.moveon.org/call/?tg=FHNY_20&cp_id=957&id=16431-1533783-M4C8e9x&t=1 ]

Congress: (800) 828-0498; pass it on!...

Joel
242-9017/876-2488
http://www.DutchessDemocracy.blogspot.com

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Also-- today's paper-- http://www.poughkeepsiejournal.com/article/20090623/NEWS12/90623002 !...

[thx to all 177 of you out there for signin' on to http://www.PetitionOnline.com/MARRIAGE -- join us now]

Poll: More New Yorkers support gay marriage
ASSOCIATED PRESS • JUNE 23, 2009

ALBANY — A poll finds growing support for same-sex marriage in New York as a bill languishing in the state Senate is scheduled for a special session. The Quinnipiac University poll finds 51 percent of New Yorkers support the legalization of same-sex marriage. Forty-one percent oppose it. This is the first time the Quinnipiac poll found majority support for the measure. Gov. David Paterson says he will compel the Senate to consider final legislative approval of the bill in a special session that he says will begin Tuesday. The Assembly already passed the bill. Paterson says he will sign it into law if the Senate passes it. The poll questioned 2,477 voters from June 16 to Sunday. It has a margin of error of plus or minus 2 points.

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Date: Tue, 23 Jun 2009 08:42:11 -0700 (PDT)
From: James Travers
Subject: Update on Earth Day bills in NY - still time to act

Just received this message from NIPIRG's Laura Haight. Please contact your NYS Senators today (ASAP) and ask them to support these important Bills when they reconvene in Special Session.

~~~~~~~~~~~~

From: Laura Haight

Date: Tuesday, June 23, 2009, 11:26 AM

The Assembly concluded its regular session at around 2 a.m. this morning, having passed all five bills we supported at this year’s Earth Day Lobby Day on May 5th. Here is an update on where these bills stand in the State Senate.

The first two bills have the best shot at passage in the Senate this year.  Please call your State Senator and urge him/her to “do the people’s business” and pass these bills when they return to session! Please also urge your Senator to cosponsor these bills.  (To read the bills and check on their status, go to http://public.leginfo.state.ny.us/menuf.cgi and type in the bill number):

Global Warming Pollution Cap (S4315, Thompson; S1526a, Morahan) – These bills would reduce New York’s climate change pollution from all sources until our greenhouse gas emissions are cut 80 percent by the year 2050. The bills, which are nearly identical, combined have 31 Senate sponsors, including 6 Republicans.

Electronic Equipment Recycling (S6047, Thompson) – In the final days of session, the Governor’s office, Assembly and Senate negotiated a new e-waste bill, which the Assembly passed early this morning. This bill would remove tons of toxic e-waste from landfills by requiring manufacturers to collect and recycle their products.

Here is an update on the other items on this year’s Earth Day Lobby Day agenda:

SEQRA Standing (S1635, Thompson) – This bill, which would restore the public’s right to enforce the State Environmental Quality Review Act (SEQRA), has been on the Senate floor calendar since May. It has 15 Senate sponsors, all Democrats.

Wetlands Protection (S4956, Thompson) – This bill, which would give New York regulatory authority over wetlands of one acre or more, has not moved out of committee in the Senate.

Bigger Better Bottle Law – In May, a federal judge delayed the implementation of the new law until April 1st, 2010 in response to a lawsuit brought by Nestle and other bottled water companies. The state is requesting that the court reconsider this decision. At this point, no further action by the Legislature is anticipated.

We cannot predict when (or even if) the impasse with the Senate leadership will be resolved, so we recommend you make these calls today, and spread the word to your activist lists.

Thanks!

--
Laura Haight, NYPIRG
518-436-0876, ext. 258
518-588-5481 (cell)

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

[note-- sadly, inexplicably, Assembly majority failed to pass Kevin Cahill's A.7611-- to make it much easier for counties, towns, cities, and villages to follow great cost-saving/green-jobs examples of Babylon and Berkeley-- http://assembly.state.ny.us/leg/?bn=7611 ...(see http://www.LIGreenHomes.com ; http://www.PetitionOnline.com/SOLAR )-- even more reason to show up for crucial forum next Tues. June 30th 6 pm at Vassar College Rockefeller Hall Rm. 300 with Babylon Town Supervisor Steve Bellone-- forum-- "Bringing Sustainable Energy Infrastructure into the Hudson Valley"-- sponsored by Hudson River Sloop Clearwater, Sustainable Hudson Valley, Hudson Valley Smart Growth Alliance, and the Vassar College Sustainability Committee-- with David Dell from the Independent Dutchess Energy Alliance (see: http://www.CambridgeEnergyAlliance.org ) introducing Bellone; Tom Kacandes/Prism Solar, Libby Murphy re: tidal power potential; email mannajo@aol.com for more info!]

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Methinx perhaps we here in Hudson Valley need to set up some sort of similar free-ice-cream-cone deal for folks who call local state legislators here in our region on this issue too!...

[ice cream for change-- who could be against that?...(let's set this up here for action in our Co. Leg.!)]

From http://www.dailygazette.com/weblogs/food-forum/2009/jun/23/62309_milk/ http://www.HWFC.com

Honest Weight Food Co-op and the group Food & Water Watch are joining on Friday in a push to make organic, rBGH-free milk available in schools.

Katrisa Centanni, the education coordinator for Honest Weight, says in an announcement that not enough is known about the effects caused by rBGH, a synthetic growth hormone used to increase milk production in dairy cows. “The potential health risks of rBGH milk include higher cancer rates,” she said.

Centanni said many retailers and manufacturers - like Wal-Mart, Kroger, Yoplait and Starbuck's - have responded to customer concerns by rejecting milk produced with BGH, but “the unintended consequence is that schools have become a dumping ground for milk that consumers are rejecting.”

They're calling Friday's event “Ice Cream for Change Day.” Anyone can come to Honest Weight that day between 10 a.m. and 5:30 p.m., learn more about rBGH-free milk, make a call to Rep. Paul Tonko's office to urge him to let area schools purchase rBGH-free and organic milk. All who do so will be offered a reward: a free ice cream cone from Adirondack Creamery.
Adirondack Creamery Ice Cream is made from hormone-free milk and cream. Paul Nasrani, founder and CEO of Adirondack Creamery, built his business on the concept “that the closer to the cow you keep the ice cream, the better it is.”

Centanni says schools should be allowed to exercise the same choices as consumers.
If you agree, or just want to know more, stop in on Friday at Honest Weight at 484 Central Ave. Find the co-op's Web site here.

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

From: "Rob Moore, Environmental Advocates of New York"

Subject: Tell Congress to Act Now to Help Stop Global Warming

In the next few days, the United States Congress will vote on
historic legislation to reduce the pollution that is changing
our climate. This vote will determine if the U.S. takes action
to help stop global warming before it's too late.

We need your help to solve climate change. Go to
http://actionnetwork.org/campaign/aces_2009 to tell your
Representative in Congress to vote "YES" on the American Clean
Energy & Security Act of 2009.

This legislation will expand the use of renewable energy such as
wind and solar, promote energy efficiency (the most
cost-effective way to reduce pollution and carbon emissions),
and curb carbon emissions by implementing a national
cap-and-trade system.

Congress needs to hear from voters like you. Go to
http://actionnetwork.org/campaign/aces_2009 to tell your
Representative that you support the Waxman-Markey climate change
bill, the American Clean Energy & Security Act of 2009.

Thank you,

Rob Moore
Executive Director
Environmental Advocates of New York

This message was sent to joeltyner@earthlink.net. To modify your email
communication preferences or update your personal profile, visit
your subscription management page at:

http://actionnetwork.org/eany/smp.tcl?nkey=iid5n344jnimktw&

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

[note re: below-- perhaps calls to Hall's, Hinchey's, Gillibrand's, Schumer's offices couldn't hurt either!]

Date: Tue, 23 Jun 2009 07:13:29 -0700

From: "Anna Galland, MoveOn.org Political Action"

[see: http://pol.moveon.org/call/?tg=FHNY_20&cp_id=957&id=16431-1533783-M4C8e9x&t=1 ]

Subject: Deadline today: Call Rep. Murphy for stronger energy bill


More than 40 members of Congress are standing up to fix the energy bill. But Rep. Murphy isn't yet one of them. Can you ask him to sign onto the Pingree-Ellison letter to strengthen the energy bill?

Representative Scott Murphy
Phone: 202-225-5614

Click Here
Dear MoveOn member,

Just weeks ago, two progressive members of Congress decided to take a stand for a stronger energy bill.

Now, thanks in part to 15,000 phone calls and faxes from MoveOn members, over 40 representatives have spoken out together for key fixes to the energy bill.

But we need more lawmakers to join them in order to counter the massive influence of the oil and coal companies.

Your representative, Scott Murphy, has not yet signed on—and the deadline is this afternoon. Can you call and ask him to sign the "Pingree-Ellison Dear Colleague letter" to strengthen the energy bill?

Representative Scott Murphy
Phone: 202-225-5614

Then report your call by clicking here:

http://pol.moveon.org/call?tg=FHNY_20&cp_id=957&id=16431-1533783-M4C8e9x&t=3

A "Dear Colleague" letter is a letter from a group of lawmakers to other members of Congress, urging some position on an issue. In this case, Representatives Chellie Pingree (D-ME) and Keith Ellison (D-MN) are ready to send a letter asking Democratic leaders to strengthen the energy bill.

Signing this letter is an easy way for other members of Congress to show their support. Since the vote is expected on Friday, the deadline to sign the letter is this afternoon.

Here are the three key changes to the energy bill that these progressive champs are calling for:

Ensure More Clean Energy for America: Increase the Renewable Electricity Standard to 30 percent by 2020, combining renewable energy and energy efficiency to deliver more clean energy jobs to the U.S. economy more quickly. Utilities would have to achieve 17 percent mandatory renewables and 10 percent mandatory efficiency by 2020, while maintaining flexibility to do either with 3 percent.
Ensure that All Coal Plants Meet Strict Global Warming Emissions Standards: Maintain or strengthen existing authority under the Clean Air Act to establish limits for global warming emissions from coal plants.
Create more Clean Energy Jobs for America and Build Resiliency to Climate Change: Reduce allocations to polluting industries in order to supplement allowance accounts that would bolster green job development and protection of vulnerable communities that are impacted first and worst by climate change. Shave allocations from fossil fuel producers and redistribute to programs that deliver energy efficiency and renewable energy, create green jobs and train workers to fill them, and protect natural resources and vulnerable communities here and around the world.
Please call Rep. Murphy right away at:

Representative Scott Murphy
Phone: 202-225-5614

Thanks for all you do.

–Anna, Adam, Joan, Noah and the rest of the team

Want to support our work? We're entirely funded by our 5 million members—no corporate contributions, no big checks from CEOs. And our tiny staff ensures that small contributions go a long way. Chip in here.

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Finally-- this just in to us from the good folks @ http://www.TrueMajority.org ....

Date: Tue, 23 Jun 2009 12:30:24 -0400 (EDT)

From: "Darcy Scott Martin TrueMajority.org"

Subject: It's 2:30 a.m. – do you know where $2 billion is?



Dear Joel,

Stop these wasteful warplanes!

 

They've never flown in combat, can't fight the Taliban, and the Secretary of Defense doesn't want them - but you're about to be charged $2 billion for these planes.
Call congress now and tell them to stop building planes we don't need, and the Pentagon doesn't want!

Unless we stop it, Congress could vote as soon as TOMORROW to spend more than $2 billion of your money on a fighter jet that even the Pentagon doesn't want. President Obama called for an end to 'weapons as usual' contracting at the Pentagon - including ending production of the F-22 fighter jet. But in a 2:30 a.m. vote, the weapons contractors were able to get enough Republican and Blue-Dog Democrat votes to slip it back in.1

Congressman Barney Frank is leading the fight for Obama's Pentagon budget, but the showdown is now and he doesn't have the votes yet. Call your member of Congress right now and tell him or her to cut these wasteful warplanes.

http://tools.advomatic.com/14/TrueSecurity

You've probably heard about the F-22 before. Designed to fight the next generation of Soviet airplanes in a war that never happened, it has never been flown in combat and has never been deployed to Iraq or Afghanistan.2 And at a cost of $351 million per plane we simply can't afford this kind of pork-barrel spending.3

We need the money to repair our crumbling schools and put people to work building a green-energy economy. But we can't shift our priorities unless we first stop pouring money into useless weapons projects like the F-22.

We're working with people like Vote Vets, Business Leaders for Sensible Priorities, and others to cut these needless warplanes.4 These allies give us a chance to win, but they're counting on us to deliver a grassroots call for change that Congress can't ignore. Call right now and tell Congress to get with the program and start investing in True Security for America.

- Darcy
Darcy Scott Martin
TrueMajority / USAction

1 - nytimes.com/2009/06/20/opinion/20sat2.html?_r=1
2 - huffingtonpost.com/jon-soltz/will-congress-put-useless_b_218853.html
3 - armscontrolcenter.org/policy/securityspending/articles/022609_fy10_topline_systems_to_watch/
4 - truesecurity.usaction.org/f22letter.pdf

Margaret Mead was right; join a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens this Sunday!...

'Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens can change the world. Indeed, it's the only thing that ever has.'

—Margaret Mead

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Hi all...

Many of you out there came out to my Mom's (Judy Malstrom's) pre-birthday gathering here May 31st at our house at 324 Browns Pond Road in Clinton (between Fiddler's Bridge Road and Schultz Hill Road); it turned into a bit of a salon/discussion on various current issues with a number of community activists present along with current/former electeds, and folks agreed it'd be fun to try to come together again to further discussion...

So-- we're starting a Sunday Salon Series of community potlucks this Sunday at 6 pm; join us if u can!...

[pass it on]

Joel
242-9017/876-2488
http://www.DutchessDemocracy.blogspot.com

[we'll be talking about issues that have been in the papers and on radio/TV this week, as well as prioritizing local action: http://www.petitiononline.com/ourtown http://www.petitiononline.com/newideas ;
http://www.petitiononline.com/zeroyes ; http://www.CommonDreams.org ; http://www.TheNation.com ]

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

From http://www.utne.com/archives/TheSalon-KeepersCompanion.aspx ...good advice for us Sunday...

The Salon-Keeper's Companion
An Utne Reader Guide to Conducting Salons, Council and Study Circles

Note: What follows is the text of our original handbook for salon-keepers, published in 1991. We should have put this online long ago, but in the interest of better being late than never, here it is. Some of the information on specific projects may be out of date. Please email any updates or corrections to webkeeper@utne.com. And please let us know how your salon is going. Post a note about when and where your group meets in the Salons Forum in Cafe Utne, our virtual community. Happy saloning!
—Leif Utne, July, 2002

Introduction

What happens if you throw a salon and people come, but nobody talks? Or worse, no one listens. Or people only talk about what they saw on television, or the clever things they said yesterday, or how oppressive the system is, or, you get the idea. Just inviting a group of people over to talk about what they're thinking and obsessing about lately does not in itself insure a successful salon. What follows are a few suggestions from some seasoned salon-keepers about how to have a salon that's stimulating, involving, and might even change the world.

Throughout this guide the word salon is used to describe a wide range of ways groups can interact.

• Traditional salons like those that seeded the French Revolution tend to emphasize spirited group discussion.

• Council, derived mainly from Native American traditions, emphasizes 'devout listening' and unpremeditated speaking.

• Study circles tend to involve reading and focused group discussion.
Each form is a response to the particular needs and interests of the people gathering together. Sometimes a group begins meeting using the salon format and evolves into a council or study circle, or some other form, like a book club, macro-analysis seminar, consciousness raising group, coven, or twelve-step program. One thing leads to another.

A Place to Meet

The word salon is French for drawing room. Salons can happen just about anywhere, but some spaces are more conducive to conversational intimacy than others. Ideally the gathering will take place in someone's home, in a space just large enough to seat the entire group in a circle. Meeting rooms in an office or church are also appropriate. There should be no extemal distractions (telephones, traffic noise, etc.) and everyone should be reasonably comfortable. Salons can work outdoors (under a tree, around a campfire, in a private garden), but the potential for interruptions outdoors is greater.

Breaking bread together is a time-honored social lubricant, but food can also get in the way of focused group conversation. Whether you gather for breakfast, lunch, teatime, or dinner, it's usually best to wait until everyone has finished eating before starting the group discussion. Most salon-keepers we've talked to feel that the best conversation happens without alcohol. Potlucks tend to work better for groups that already know each other. For a new salon it's usually better for the host to provide the refreshments (and possibly invite contributions to cover the costs).

Participants

Utne Reader Neighborhood Salons are not intended to be the exclusive domain of Utne Reader subscribers. Feel free to invite anyone you think would enjoy the conversation and contribute to the group. Salons can be as small as 5 or 6 people or as large as 20 to 30. A salon in San Francisco called A New American Place has grown to 80 participants. After light refreshments in one room they enter another, listen to a short presentation, break into small groups for 45 minutes to discuss what they've heard, and then reconvene for general conversation.

At the Utne Reader's Altemative Press Reading and Dining Salon, we've found that groups of 12 to 18 participants (approximately five regular participants and 10 guests) seem to work best.

Convenor/Facilitator

The roles of convenor and facilitator are distinct functions. The convenor invites the guests, provides the location, arranges the refreshments, etc. The facilitator, who could be the same person, initiates the conversation, modulates its tone, guides its direction and focus, remains aware of the time, draws out the meek, and gently but firmly quiets the boor, while witnessing and participating in the process.

The first order of business when a new salon is assembled, is to ask the group if anyone is an experienced group facilitator who'd like to serve in that role for this particular gathering. If no one steps forward the convener should facilitate.

The First Meeting

Important goals for the first meeting are to have fun, meet everyone, and draw out the participants' ideas for what the group might do together.

Upon hearing the scraping of flatware against china, the alert facilitator begins to ready him/herself to lead the group discussion. After the dishes are cleared and the coffee or tea has been poured, the facilitator welcomes the guests and announces the beginning of the salon.

Start by asking each person to take a minute and say something about who they are. Just a few sentences should be enough. Then go around the circle a second time asking people what drew them to attend and what they would most like to see happen. Encourage wild ideas. This round could be prefaced by reading the following list of possible purposes for such a group:

1. Conversation? Exchange of ideas with kindred spirits on topics that people care about. What are you thinking and obsessing about lately?

2. Trend-watching? Tapping into the zeitgeist by making explicit your own previously unarticulated thoughts and hearing the thinking of others. This is a primary purpose of Utne Reader's salons.

3. Learning? Formal presentations by group members or invited guests on any subject of mutual interest ? a time-tested and reliable way to start the discussion.

4. Co-creation? Playful collaboration for the head, hands and heart. Berkeley salon-keeper Jaida n'ha Sandra hosts monthly gatherings for amateur poetry reading (no criticism allowed), collage-making, musical jam sessions with or without instruments, mask-making, contact dance, comedy improvisation, round-robin story writing, even Ukrainian egg-dying.

5. Support? Developing your own response to critical social and cultural issues (e.g., clarifying your own thinking, enriching and balancing this with other perspectives, validating what you've been intuiting, filling gaps in your knowledge, etc.).

6. publishing a newsletter, forming a Green political action committee, starting a calypso band, developing a co-housing project, or creating a human/dolphin pod family...whatever.

It may be that your group never reaches consensus about what to do together. It may subdivide into a variety of forms. Hurrah! Go forth and multiply.

Council

Another way a group can be together is in council. Whereas salons are more freewheeling and spontaneous, council is more deliberate and meditative. Salons work well for groups of individuals who haven't met before. Council works better for groups that already have some history, although this is by no means a prerequisite to its use. Salons are more social. Council is more ceremonial. In salons, the emphasis is on conversation. In council, the emphasis is on community. Council is a way to go deeply into an issue, to create a sense of 'groupness,' to seek higher wisdom and guidance, to open the heart and speak truth.

A good description of council was presented by Jack Zimmerman and Virginia Coyle in Utne Reader (March/April 1991, pp. 79-85). Following are a few guidelines paraphrased from their article:

Talking Sticks and Children's Fire

We often set three simple rules for council: Speak honestly, be brief, and listen from the heart. The group chooses one or two leaders or facilitators whose job it is to keep the process on track. To empower each person to speak in turn, a 'talking stick' or other object is chosen to be passed around the circle–traditionally clockwise, in the 'sun direction.' The talking stick can be anything from a flower to a traditional hand-crafted artifact.

If possible, a fire is built in the center of the circle or a candle is lit to set the mood for storytelling. We have come to call this the 'children's fire,' following the Sundance teaching of Hyemeyohst's Storm. When we say, 'Never cross the children's fire,' we mean no one is to interrupt the person holding the talking stick (except, as in the traditional Native American councils, to express approval by saying, 'Ho!').

Devout Listening and Unpremeditated Speaking

One of the great challenges of council is not to be thinking about what you're going to say until it's your turn to speak. Preparing your contribution before you receive the talking stick obviously diminishes its spontaneity and responsiveness to what others have said. A good practice is to wait until the talking stick is in your hands before pausing to see what springs to mind. A few simple silent reflections can be useful: Will my speaking serve me? Will the circle or community be served? Will the 'bigger picture,' life, God....be served? When doubts remain, it is usually best to take the leap. Boldness is rarely inappropriate.

If the ground rules are stated clearly at the outset it will rarely be necessary for the leader to interrupt anyone for rambling or speaking inappropriately. When interruption is necessary, remember that 'gentle decisiveness' is the mark of a good leader.

Councils can be open or thematic, depending on the group's needs.

Even in an open council a theme often emerges, perhaps triggered by one person's story or the general movement of what is said. Often several people in the circle find they are dealing with the same issue and so the council ends up focusing on that topic. Any member of the circle may shift the theme or propose an entirely new course for the circle. Leaders need to continuously consider the truth of the moment, regardless of who may be speaking it.

Normal witnessing is a basic part of council that brings a different perspective to the circle. One approach is to designate a few regular members of the group as witnesses on a rotating basis, or visitors can be asked to participate in this way. Witnesses sit in the circle but are silent as the talking stick goes around, listening with as much of the 'long view' as they can muster. Then after everyone has spoken, the witnesses are asked to comment, not just about the statements already made, but also about the council process itself. Often a witness will have something valuable to tell the leaders about their way of handling the council.

There are as many styles of council leadership as there are council leaders. Some leaders are active and directive whereas others stay very much in the background, letting the process unfold on its own. Experienced leaders vary their style as the situation demands, taking their cues from the council's purpose and the realities of the moment.

Sometimes a leader will initiate the round in order to set an appropriate tone. At other times the leader may choose to speak last, using his or her turn not only to speak on a personal level, but also to respond to what others have said and to summarize the central themes that emerged. When there are two leaders, both of these important functions can be accomplished in the same council. If time permits, the leader may send the stick around a second time or place it in the center for further exploration.

As in the ancient circles of elders, council members come to know that they each bring a piece of the truth to the circle–a piece essential in itself, but only a part of the whole. The passion of a personal vision becomes part of the larger truth of the circle. When council is working, we all experience this truth without any threat to personal identity and without the 'tyranny of the collective.' Everyone recognizes what's really happening and sees the path to 'right action,' often at the same time, and usually accompanied by the special joy inherent in the co-visioning process.

This experience of simultaneous common realization should not be confused with the democratic process treasured by our political idealism. In council we rarely determine which position is held by the majority–by taking a vote, for example. Sometimes a single individual in touch with the larger truth–and clear enough to reflect it in council–can eventually bring the entire circle into focus. On more than a few occasions we have experienced a young child being the truth-holder in a council of elders.

Simply put, the essence of a council is participation in an interdependence that frees us from the bondage of self-absorption and opens the door to spirited co-creation. 

Study circles

Study circles are a long established form of adult learning particularly suited for groups that want to increase their knowledge about political or social issues and their ability to effect change. Begun in the 19th century, study circles enjoy widespread use in Scandinavia, where a third of the adult population participates. The Swedish government even subsidizes study circles materials fees. The following description is adapted from a series of 'Resource Briefs' published by the Study Circle Resource Center:
Participation in a study circle implies a certain commitment. Ideally 5 to 20 participants meet once a week for at least three sessions and rarely for more than five or six. Each discussion lasts approximately two hours and is directed by a well-prepared leader whose role is to aid in lively but focused discussion. Participants receive in advance about an hour's worth of reading material covering the topic for the session.

Two individuals, the organizer and the leader, are central to the creation and success of a study circle. The study circle organizer selects or develops the reading materials, recruits participants, arranges the logistics of the meetings, and chooses the discussion leader. The study circle leader stimulates and moderates the discussion and guides the group toward the goals that it has agreed upon.

The leader does not need to be an expert or even the most knowledgeable person in the group. However, the leader should be the most well-prepared person in the room. The leader guides the study circle through his or her familiarity with the reading material, preparation of questions to aid discussion, previous reflection about the directions in which the discussion might go, knowledge of the people and personalities in the group, and a clear understanding of the goals of the study circle.

The most difficult aspects of leading discussion groups include keeping the discussion focused, handling aggressive participants, and keeping one's own ego at bay in order to truly hear participants. A background of leading small group discussion or meetings is helpful.

The goal of a study circle is not to master a text or to leam a lot of facts, but rather to deepen understanding and judgment. This can occur in a focused discussion when people exchange views freely and consider a variety of viewpoints. The process–democratic discussion among equals–is as important as the content.

Participants should commit to attending all meetings, help keep the discussion on track, address their remarks to the group rather than to the leader, listen carefully to others, speak freely without monopolizing the discussion, and maintain an open mind, even when they disagree with what is being said.

It is not necessary for a study circle to achieve consensus. In some cases a group will split. There's no need to hammer out agreement.

Close each session with a summary and perhaps an evaluation. Review the overall goals of the program and discuss whether the group has moved toward those goals.

The Study Circles Resource Center, in addition to the materials from which the preceding passages were excerpted, now offers the Public Talk Series, discussion aides designed to stimulate exploration of such issues as 'America's Role in the Middle East,' 'American Society and Economic Policy: What Should Our Goals Be?,' 'America's Role in the World,' and 'The Changing Shape of Security in Europe.' Several others in the series, which is free of charge, are due out this year covering such topics as cultural diversity, universal health care, economic conversion, and the death penalty. SCRC invites suggestions for other topics that groups would be interested in discussing.

For their Introduction to Study Circles and other materials, call or write them at the address listed in the accompanying resource box.

Conclusion
Salons, council, and study circles are just a few of the countless ways a group of people can interact. The form your group embraces and evolves into will be unique to your particular mix of personalities and goals. We'd like to keep in touch with you, to find out what your experience is, what problems you're having, and where you could use some support. We'll report back to you and other salons about what works and what doesn't. We may find a way to do this in Utne Reader–please send snapshots of your group, two to five people per frame. We also may develop a newsletter to provide you with feedback and to link this remarkable expanding network.
Remember, think globally, act vocally.
—Eric Utne, 1991

Salon Resources

Study Circles
Free information is available from:
Study Circles Resource Center
Route 169, Box 203
Pomfret, CT 06258
203/928-2616
scrc@studycircles.org
www.studycircles.org

Council
An instruction booklet on Council by Jack Zimmerman and Virginia Coyle is available for $2.50, and a 38-minute video called Speaking from the Heart is available for $25 (or get both for $26 + postage) from:
The Ojai Foundation
9739 Ojai-Santa Paula Road
Ojai, CA 93023
Voice:805.646.8343
Fax: 805.646.2456
contact@ojaifoundation.org
www.ojaifoundation.org

Electronic Salons
The WELL
The granddaddy of virtual communities
www.well.com